You slipped on a wet floor in a Bronx supermarket. You tripped on a cracked sidewalk outside a Brooklyn apartment building. You fell on an icy building entrance on a Manhattan office block. All three accidents are different in legally significant ways — different defendants, different standards of proof, and different deadlines. Here is how premises liability works in New York City.
The Duty of Care: What Every Property Owner Owes You
Every person who owns, controls, or maintains real property in New York owes a duty of care to keep that property in a reasonably safe condition for anyone who enters it lawfully. This duty applies to commercial property owners, residential landlords, building managers, retail stores, restaurants, and — in some circumstances — the City of New York.
The specific standard depends on why you were on the property. As an "invitee" — a customer in a store, a visitor in an office building, a tenant's guest — you are owed the highest duty: the owner must take affirmative steps to inspect the property, discover defects, and either repair them or warn you about them.
The Notice Requirement: The Key to Most Slip and Fall Cases
To hold a property owner liable for a slip and fall, you generally must prove that the owner or their agents knew about the dangerous condition — either actually knew about it, or should have known about it because it existed long enough that reasonable inspection would have discovered it. This is the "notice" element.
⚖️ Actual vs. Constructive Notice
Actual notice: The owner or their employee knew about the condition — there was a prior complaint, a prior incident report, or an employee who saw the hazard and failed to fix it. Constructive notice: The condition existed for so long that the owner "should have known" about it through reasonable inspection. A puddle that formed 30 seconds before you slipped is different from a recurring leak that has left a wet floor for weeks.
This is why incident reports matter so much. If there is a prior incident report for the same condition, or if employees acknowledge the condition had existed for a period of time, that establishes notice that can overcome the "we didn't know" defense.
Sidewalk Liability in NYC: It Depends on the Property Type
Sidewalk liability in New York City is governed by NYC Administrative Code §7-210, enacted in 2003. The rule depends on the type of property adjacent to the sidewalk:
- Commercial property: The owner is responsible for maintaining the adjacent sidewalk in a reasonably safe condition. Failure to do so makes them liable for injuries.
- Multi-family residential (5+ units): Same as commercial — owner is responsible for the adjacent sidewalk.
- One-to-four family residential: The owner is generally not liable for sidewalk defects unless they created the defect or used the sidewalk for commercial purposes. The City of New York retains liability for these sidewalks.
⚠️ City-Owned Sidewalks: 90-Day Notice of Claim
If your fall occurred on a sidewalk adjacent to a one-to-four family home, city park, or other government property, your potential claim is against the City of New York. You must file a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the accident — this is an absolute prerequisite for suing any government entity in New York. Missing this deadline permanently bars your claim.
NYCHA Properties
New York City Housing Authority properties — public housing complexes across the five boroughs — are government property. Falls in stairwells, on walkways, or in common areas of NYCHA developments are claims against NYCHA and require a Notice of Claim within 90 days. NYCHA's often-deferred maintenance creates significant hazards in many developments, and these cases are both valid and actively litigated.
Proving Your Case: What You Must Establish
To win a slip and fall case in New York, you must prove:
- There was a dangerous or defective condition on the property
- The defendant owned, controlled, or maintained the property
- The defendant had actual or constructive notice of the condition
- The condition was the proximate cause of your fall and injuries
- You suffered damages as a result
New York's pure comparative negligence rule means your own fault — if any — reduces but does not eliminate your recovery. If a jury finds you 20% at fault for not looking where you were going, your recovery is reduced by 20%, but you still collect the remaining 80%.
Evidence You Need to Preserve Immediately
Slip and fall cases turn on evidence — and evidence disappears fast. These are the most time-sensitive actions after your fall:
- Photographs of the exact hazard — wet floor, broken tile, uneven pavement, icy surface — taken before it is cleaned or repaired
- The hazard's dimensions and exact location — measured and documented
- Incident report — request one from the manager or property owner before you leave
- Witness information — names and phone numbers of anyone who saw the fall or the condition
- Surveillance camera identification — note every camera that may have captured the fall
- Medical attention same day — creates an immediate medical record connecting the fall to your injuries
💡 The Store's Incident Report Is Your First Victory
A store incident report acknowledges the fall, records witness information, and sometimes includes an employee's description of the condition. If a manager tells you there is no incident report form or refuses to take one, note that refusal in writing. An attorney can subpoena the store's incident log and internal communications.
Statute of Limitations
The statute of limitations for premises liability claims in New York is generally 3 years from the date of the accident under CPLR §214. However:
- Claims against the City of New York, NYCHA, or other government entities require a Notice of Claim within 90 days, followed by a lawsuit within 1 year and 90 days
- Claims arising from a construction accident may be subject to Labor Law statutes with different rules
- Claims involving children have extended statutes of limitations
Questions About Your Case?
Free consultation — 24/7. No fee unless we win. We serve all five NYC boroughs.
📞 Call (212) 300-3191 Now